Short answer: a well-fitted dress shirt has a collar you can slip two fingers into when buttoned, a shoulder seam that ends at the edge of your shoulder, a chest with no pulling at the buttons, sleeves that end at the base of your thumb, cuffs snug enough not to slide over your hand, a body with no billowing at the waist, and a tail long enough to stay tucked when you raise your arms.
The 8-Point Dress Shirt Fit Checklist
1. Collar
Button the collar. You should be able to slide two fingers flat between the collar and your neck. Any tighter and it will feel like a noose by mid-afternoon; any looser and the collar will collapse under a tie. The collar points should touch your chest and sit under the jacket lapels.
2. Shoulders
The shoulder seam should sit right at the edge of your shoulder bone. If it drops onto your arm the shirt is too big; if it sits on top of your shoulder the shirt is too small.
3. Chest
Stand straight and look at the buttons. If the placket pulls into an X shape or you can see gaps between buttons, the chest is too tight. You should be able to pinch about 5 to 8 cm of spare cloth either side.
4. Sleeve length
With arms relaxed, the cuff should end at the base of your thumb, where your wrist meets your hand. Under a jacket you want about a centimetre of cuff showing.
5. Sleeve width
The sleeve should follow your arm without clinging. Too much width flaps; too little restricts movement when you reach forward.
6. Cuffs
A buttoned cuff should be snug enough that it does not slide down over your hand, but loose enough to fit a watch on one wrist. Bespoke shirts can be made with a slightly larger cuff on your watch hand.
7. Waist
Tucked in, the shirt should not balloon over your belt. A little blousing is fine for movement; a parachute is not. Darts at the back or a tapered side seam fix this.
8. Length
A dress shirt meant to be tucked should cover your seat and stay tucked when you raise both arms overhead. A casual shirt meant to be worn untucked should end around the middle of your trouser zip.
Slim Fit, Regular Fit or Custom Fit?
Ready-made shirts are cut on a standard block: slim, regular or classic. Each assumes a fixed ratio between neck, chest, waist and arm length. If your proportions differ, for example an athletic chest with a slim waist or long arms with a short torso, no off-the-peg size fits everywhere. That is why so many men buy shirts that fit the collar and then live with a baggy waist.
A custom shirt solves this by cutting a pattern from your measurements. At Manhattan Tailors we take neck, chest, waist, hip, shoulder, both arm lengths, both wrists and back length, note your posture, and make a first shirt for you to wear and wash before the rest of the order is cut.
How to Tell if a Shirt Is Too Tight or Too Loose
- Too tight: buttons pulling, collar marks on your neck, fabric straining across the back when you reach forward.
- Too loose: fabric gathering above your belt, shoulder seams on your upper arm, sleeves covering your hands.
Fabric Changes the Fit
Cotton shrinks slightly after the first washes, usually around the collar and sleeve length. A good shirtmaker allows for this. Stretch blends feel comfortable but lose shape faster. In Hong Kong's humidity, two-ply cotton poplin, fine twill and linen are the most comfortable choices.
Getting Shirts Made in Hong Kong
Our bespoke shirts are cut to your measurements, with your choice of collar, cuff, placket, pocket and monogram. Our most popular order is the 6 custom shirts package for HK$2,350. Once your pattern is on file, you can reorder from anywhere in the world.
Frequently Asked Questions
How tight should a dress shirt collar be?
When buttoned, you should be able to slide two fingers flat between the collar and your neck.
Where should the sleeves of a dress shirt end?
With your arms relaxed, the cuff should end at the base of your thumb, so about a centimetre shows below a jacket sleeve.
How do I know if my shirt is too big?
The shoulder seams sit on your upper arm, the sleeves cover part of your hand and fabric balloons over your belt when tucked in.
Are custom shirts worth it?
If your proportions differ from standard sizes, yes. A custom shirt fits the collar, chest, waist and sleeves at the same time, which a ready-made size often cannot.
Ready to be measured? Book Your Appointment at our Tsim Sha Tsui shop, Unit E, G/F Mercantile House, 186 Nathan Road, or message us on WhatsApp on +852 9773 2691.